Crisis Management: How to respond when an influencer posts a negative review about your brand

The ‘Influencer phenomenon’ of 2009 saw huge influencers such as Zoella, Tanya Burr and Pewdiepie launch onto YouTube screens worldwide. Since then the content creation market has only continued to snowball. Now the influencer marketing industry is estimated to be worth a staggering $13.8 billion. With new social media platforms creating a path of influence for almost anything, this market growth doesn’t look like it will be slowing anytime soon. The huge scale and success of the industry means it is no surprise that the majority of brands have now capitalised on this form of marketing. You don’t have to scroll for long to see an example of an influencer promoting a brand, service or product on your feed and for good reason too.

Some of the UK’s most successful influencers have tens, and hundreds of thousands of followers. This offers brands a ready-made, and engaged audience to communicate with. Not only this but, unlike traditional advertising, the intention of influencer curated content is that it is ‘real’ and provides its audience with an authentic and relatable interpretation of the brand they are promoting.

Here at Action, we often work with some of the fitness industries top content creators and social media influencers to share incredible fitness experiences far and wide. Take a look at the recent Orangetheory Fitness influencer event we helped run and capture here.

However, working with an influencer comes with its risks. There is nothing stopping an influencer sharing a negative review of a brand too. In fact, this year, a whole trend was born out of doing just that. ‘De-influencing’ sees social content creators actively discouraging their followers to engage with a brand or product for whatever reason they see fit, with common issues straddling sustainability, diversity and affordability.

Whether ‘de-influenced’ or ‘cancelled’, the same large-scale reach that can lead to success for a brand partnering with an influencer can also be detrimental when things go wrong… We’ve previously written about ‘Managing a brand reputation when things go wrong’ from a press point of view, read that here.

What should brands do if they are the target of ‘de-influencing’ or receive an influencer negative review.

Firstly, act quickly but efficiently to gather all the facts

It is important to gather all details relating to the matter and to understand the root cause. This will help to determine whether the negative post has derived from a negative experience with your brand or simply a misalignment. Depending on the situation this could include details like dates, times, locations, product details, number of social posts and levels of engagement. 

Remain authentic and personable

Once all the facts are gathered it is important to reach out to the influencer swiftly. If feasible, a phone call is a good way of communicating as it is much more authentic and personable than email or social media communication where tone and meaning can easily get lost.

The call can be used to re-confirm all the details from your fact finding, before working with the influencer to create a personalised plan of how the issue will be resolved. Following up on the call, in an email is a good idea to reaffirm the plans, helping to regain trust in the brand as well as ensuring a solid paper trail for reference.

Stay true to your brand values

Not everyone will be suited to, or love, every aspect of a brand. If you market yourselves as the most hardcore HIIT class, then you will generally attract a certain demographic, with a certain fitness ability. So, in the face of resistance, instead of jumping to promise change to win over the influencer, remain respectful and grateful for the feedback while backing your brand’s values. That’s not to say you shouldn’t be accommodating, but you can’t be all things to all people.

If you receive a negative review from an influencer – don’t do nothing

Most importantly, don’t do ‘nothing’. We have all seen examples of brands receiving negative comments on their social posts and these simply being left un-responded to. Not only does this show the brand to be unengaged with their followers but also that they don’t value the feedback or experience of their customers. 

Learn from the experience

Once the situation has been rectified, take time to reflect and evaluate. However big or small, there are always valuable insights that can be drawn from the situation and used to improve future collaborations and ways of working with influencers for success.

How to engage journalists on social media

Finally, there will always be times where things go wrong and in the world of influencing it is difficult to stop a content creator and influencer sharing a negative review or thoughts if they are set on doing so. However, there are a few measures that can be taken to limit the chances:

Research: Before you select the influencers you want to work with, make sure to conduct in-depth research. This could delve into their previous collaboration, what they stand for, their credibility, their engagement rate and their content to decipher whether they align with your own brand values.

Communication: Ensure open channels of communication with the influencer both before, during and after the partnership, and be transparent on what is expected on both sides.

Welcome feedback: Once the partnership is wrapped, follow up to thank the influencer for their part in the collaboration while welcoming feedback and constructive criticism, creating an open space for any issues to be discussed and resolved privately and away from social media.

As a full service agency, we’re experts in crisis management, whether on social media, national press or other outlets. We look after social media channels, press, marketing, advertising, design, content creation and much more for our clients. If you’re interested in finding out how we can help grow your brand then get in touch: info@action-group.co.uk

How to manage brand reputation when things go wrong

What’s the best way to manage your brand reputation when in crisis?

A brand crisis can strike at anytime and can spread across social media like wildfire. It’s important to be cool, calm and collected when responding to any threats that could be potentially damaging. As industry experts having dealt with many crises, here are our recommendations to ensuring the safety of your brand.

Stop and Think. Avoid a knee-jerk response that you’ll later regret. It is important to respond as quickly as possible, as staying silent won’t help your reputation. But do make sure you pause to gather all the facts before you do so.

As soon as a crisis hits, people will start discussing it on social media. The speed of dialogue on social can destroy a brand in less than 48 hours, so get your response together as quick as you can and demonstrate that you are engaging with the problem.

Honesty is always the best policy; if you’ve made a mistake, apologise and own it. Looking to obscure the truth is only likely to compound a crisis if it ever resurfaces, with catastrophic consequences for your brand reputation.

Consider the value of actions as well as words.  We are more likely to forgive a brand when it takes proactive action to set things right, or prevent a reoccurrence of the incident.

Be human in your response; falling back on overly corporate language risks diluting your response and giving the impression the brand doesn’t care.

How do you stop the situation escalating?

Again, make sure you have all the facts before you say anything. Misrepresenting the situation will reflect extremely badly on you, making it seem that your organisation is not in control or incompetent.

Brief internally within your organisation to minimise gossip and rumours. Do this as quickly as you can because any leaks will make the situation worse. Ask your teams not to speak to media and ensure any media enquiries that come in are passed on your comms team.

Ensure any statement you release addresses key concerns and doesn’t spark uncertainly or leave people with more questions. Only issue approved statements on social media. Responding to individual comments will only fuel the fire.

Your initial response and statement should not come from the most senior person within the business, for example the CEO. This leaves room to demonstrate that you are also ramping up your response should a crisis escalate further.

Should a brand always say sorry?

Saying sorry is not obligatory. Apologising can demonstrate brand weakness, but not apologising when you are at fault can also be hugely damaging.  It’s smart to work an apology into a wider narrative. Perhaps emphasise how out of character this sort of incident is for the brand, for example, putting the incident in to context by highlighting it’s the first time this has happened in a decade.

If your organisation is not directly at fault – perhaps if what has happened is the fault of a partner or supplier – you could still demonstrate disappointment or explain you feel let down. Whatever stance you decide to take, be sincere. A perfunctory statement is almost worse than no statement at all.

What are the key things to consider when giving or writing a public response to the situation?

Explain what went wrong and why it’s not going to happen again, be sincere and transparent.

Control the narrative. If there is lots of speculation and rumours around an incident address it head on and clarify the truth of the situation.

Give people a reason to forgive you, this could be explaining what you’ve already done to rectify the situation or what you plan to do.

Consider who is delivering the apology. Does the severity of the incident match up with the seniority of the person giving the statement?  If it’s a live apology is the person sufficiently media-trained to deliver the appropriate response without risk of making things worse?

Get positive messages into your statement to balance out the negative backlash but keep what you’re are saying relevant to the issue being discussed.  Don’t say too much or you risk it being cut on air or in print.

Hopefully you will never have to deploy crisis management, but if you find yourself in that situation, being equipped with this advice will keep your brand reputation intact.

Overall, remember that every crisis is different and your approach will need to change. Each will need to be considered on its own merits and addressed based on the situation at hand.

If you need help managing your brand and making an impact on the health and fitness sector, get in touch with us: info@action-group.co.uk