
“I think you are the first PR person ever to acknowledge the criteria and break it down for me to show me that the case study you are suggesting truly ticks every box. Thank you! I wish every PR person did that. How very refreshing you are!”
I received this message in response to a recent email pitch. Initially delighted to have hit the proverbial nail on the head (and secured the client in the forthcoming feature), I then felt rather sad for our industry. A good email pitch should be part of our skillset: not a cause for such praise and delight.
Email pitching is a core PR skill and never more important than during the pandemic. Most journalists are working from home, (rightly) guarding their personal phone numbers and, therefore, requiring PRs to send ‘cold’ email pitches where, previously, a ‘warm up’ phone call might have helped to pave the way. You can contact journalists on social media, but we recommend emails as the first port of call.
So, in a bid to help more PRs get effusive thanks for a well-pitched story, here are a few rules of thumb we follow here at Action Group:
What makes a great email pitch?
Be personable
Never, EVER, send a mass email in the vain hope that if you send enough one will work. Make each approach personal and tailor your pitch carefully to the journalist you’re emailing. If they have given a ‘shout out’ for a piece, make sure you can answer their brief completely. They know what they want: don’t try and turn it your way.
If you’re sending a pre-emptive pitch, do your homework on their style, recent stories, opinions and views. Aim to match your pitch to these: if it doesn’t match well, you’re emailing the wrong person!
Use their name – of course at the start of your pitch, but also at the end to acknowledge them and show this is not a mass email.
Intrigue them
Take time to create an eye-catching subject line. It’s what they’ll see first. Keep it under 10 words and interesting enough so they’ll want to open your email and read more. If you’re offering something genuinely ‘exclusive’ or ‘brand new’, stating that will catch their attention. We have had incredible success reaching out to journalists when we launched an emergency charity appeal during a global pandemic.
Get to the point of your pitch
Journalists will scan the first few sentences before deciding whether to read on. Don’t waste time asking how their week is going or what the weather is like. Also, don’t take their valuable time explaining yourself or your company. Get straight to the point. Grab their attention and show why your story is relevant to them and their audience.
Keep to the point
The ‘Five Ws’ that act as guiding principles in a press release apply to email pitches too. Remember to cover off: Who, What, When, Where & Why. (If you don’t, you’re simply creating work for the journalist to ask the question/s not answered).
Don’t rely on an attachment to ‘sell’ your pitch: journalists rarely have time to open unsolicited email attachments and are understandably wary too.
Leave the kitchen sink where it is
Don’t be tempted to throw a load of other things into your email. The ‘while I’ve got you, let me pitch five more random ideas’ tactic isn’t a good one.
Nudge – but don’t nag
If you don’t get a reply to your carefully pitched email, you can send a polite follow-up to check if they’d had a moment to read your email pitch and if it’s of interest. Ensure the original email is in the body of the follow-up: asking a journalist to check back through their inbox (which most likely sees 100s of new emails drop in each day) will not go well.
And finally…
On those occasions when your email pitch doesn’t go your way, accept that the journalist wasn’t interested this time. Be gracious in defeat and don’t be put off trying another way another day.
When the pitch does go your way and you successfully land your story, remember to say thank you (you’d be surprised how many journalists are surprised – and delighted – to be thanked!) And don’t be complacent about coverage: each new email pitch needs to be equally targeted and convincing.


